Architectural Columns

Category Archives: Wrongful Termination

Federal Workers: What Now?

A group of professionally dressed men and women stand together in a modern office setting with stairs in the background. They are diverse in age, gender, and ethnicity, with confident and friendly expressions. A blue graphic overlay includes text that reads "New Blog - Federal Workers: What Now?" Below the main text, a website link is provided: "Read More: www.satterlaw.com/blog"

If you are a federal worker, first things first: You’re not crazy. What’s happening is completely bizarro-land.

            Now that we’ve got that clear, what do you do?

The lawyer answer (sorry) is: It Depends. The reality is that tons and tons of these terminations are illegal, but there are different ways they may be illegal.

For example, career civil service workers – even probationary employees – are protected by merit systems principles, which include protection from “arbitrary action, personal favoritism, or coercion for partisan political purposes.” 5 U.S.C. § 2301(b)(8). (That’s a federal statute right there btw, not some loosy-goosy theory about fair treatment. It’s the actual law.) Because of this requirement, there are procedures that agencies have to follow when they are terminating a bunch of people to cut costs, otherwise known as a Reduction In Force or “RIF.” RIFs are governed by a procedure for making sure that terminations are made based on merit system factors, for example, examination of performance ratings and length of service. 5 U.S.C. §3502. Federal employees who are getting RIF’d are supposed to get 60 days’ notice and information about rights to reemployment and career transition assistance before the termination goes into effect.

Additionally, many Federal employees are union members, and as such have additional protections including a statute that requires a union contract to provide grievance procedures. 5 U.S.C. §1721(a)(1). Another source of protection is in the federal civil rights laws prohibiting discrimination, such as Title VII, Rehabilitation Act (prohibiting disability discrimination), and Age Discrimination in Employment Act (ADEA).

            What to do?

OK first, re-read the first sentence of this article. This is legit Wacky-land and you are legit encountering stuff that could have been dreamed up by Salvadore Dali. Or Kafka.

Second, call your union. As of the writing of this article, an AI-assisted search (so take this with a grain of salt) states that there are currently 101 class actions involving federal workers. Your union will know if you’re part of one of these. If you’re not, see if there are other ways your union can help you, such as filing a grievance.

If you’re not union, or if the union can’t help with your particular situation, get hold of a reputable workplace lawyer. For sure it’s expensive. This is your livelihood.

Whatever you do, don’t just assume there’s nothing you can do. There are super-talented, intelligent people fighting for your rights. Make sure they know your situation so they can help you plan your next step.

It’s (Probably) Not Wrongful Termination If You’re Not Terminated.

A promotional image for a new blog post features a man in a suit holding a cardboard box filled with office supplies, including binders, folders, and notebooks. The text overlay reads: 'NEW BLOG POST' in large, bold black letters. Above this, within a speech bubble-like shape, the text says: 'It's (Probably) Not Wrongful Termination If You're Not Terminated.' At the bottom, the website URL www.satterlaw.com/blog is displayed.

 

Employees who feel they are about to be fired for illegal reasons sometimes choose to quit, thinking it will spare them the embarrassment of being terminated. In other cases, employers might try to avoid firing an employee by making the workplace so hostile that the employee feels forced to resign.

What many employees don’t realize is that quitting can cost them the opportunity to file a wrongful termination case against their employer. To pursue a wrongful termination claim, you must prove that you were actually terminated.

In New York State, a wrongful termination claim requires the employee to demonstrate the following:

  1. They are part of a recognized protected class.
  2. They were qualified for the position in question.
  3. They were discharged.
  4. Their discharge occurred under circumstances that suggest the motivation for the termination was prohibited by law.

However, if you voluntarily quit your job, you may lose your ability to pursue a wrongful termination claim. That’s because you can no longer demonstrate that you were discharged, which is a necessary element of the claim. In most cases, if you’re not terminated, you cannot claim wrongful termination.

Additionally, only a small percentage of individuals who quit their jobs will meet the requirements to successfully bring a constructive discharge lawsuit. Proving a constructive discharge case is difficult, and it’s often challenging to demonstrate that the work environment was so intolerable that resignation was the only option.

If you feel that your employer is about to illegally fire you, or if you’re dealing with a hostile work environment, it’s crucial to consult an employment attorney before you make any decision, especially before quitting. Quitting could significantly impact your legal rights.

 

217 S. Salina St., 6th Fl.,
Syracuse, NY 13202

T: 315-471-0405
F: 315-471-7849

Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. This site is published for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.  This site neither creates nor implies an attorney-client relationship.

Find us on Mastodon: @WorkplaceLawyer@union.place